Damaged
Quoyle is yet another of Kevin Spacey's damaged souls, but a nice one. Quoyle is also the central character in The Shipping News, another of director Lasse Hallström's chronicles of eccentric sweetness, based on E. Annie Proulx's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel and slightly less cloying than Chocolat. Poor Quoyle.
Such is the film's overriding sentiment, that Quoyle
is a victim, beaten down emotionally and by life
circumstances, working so hard to find his way to some
kind of solid ground. Just so, he's introduced as a
child being tossed into a lake by his cruel father. As
Quoyle struggles to reach the surface, the camera
locates you under water with him: the water closes in
over him, he struggles for breath, bubbles churn as he
works his arms and legs uselessly. The scene is
alarming rather than dreamy (as drowning scenes often
are in the movies), and yet, the most jarring element
is that throughout the boy's panic, you can clearly
hear his father yelling at him to "Swim!" while his
figure shimmers against the sky, from Quoyle's soggy
point of view. And even if Quoyle can't hear what his
father's saying, you hear it plainly, as the boy might
hear it inside his submerged head: "Ain't got all day,
boy!"
So okay, dad's a monster. This isn't something you
couldn't know from what Quoyle might actually be
experiencing, but the film hammers home the point, as
if you might miss it otherwise: you must pity Quoyle.
Such graceless emotional instruction pervades The
Shipping News. Quite like another of Hallström's
quirky melodramas, The Cider House Rules, this
The Shipping News is interested in laying out
the interior life of its protagonist. It does so with
repeated flashbacks, not only to his childhood
drowning terrors, but also to evil deeds done by his
pirate ancestors and the violent death of his trampy
wife, Petal (Cate Blanchett), events that he hears
about and then imagines in the most literal ways, in
order that you not miss his torments. With these
dreadful memories and imaginings in tow, Quoyle
becomes yet another of Hallström's idiosyncratic
characters with dark histories. Such characters tend
to look intricate and unpredictable at first, until
you remember that this is a formula in itself.
Consider as well that this is Hallström's second movie
featuring a harsh environment, traumatic abortion, and
man-child hero as key elements, and you may be
wondering if you much care about Quoyle at all.
The initial glimpse of Quoyle's horrific childhood
leads quickly into his adulthood: the drowning child
morphs into Kevin Spacey, lumpy and listless while
working as an inker for a newspaper in Poughkeepsie,
New York. His life changes abruptly one rainy day when
Petal leaps into his car at a gas station, to escape
her boyfriend, and commands, "Let's go!" (Shades of
his father: you can't help but get it.) He buys her a
hot diner meal, she takes him raucously to bed. They
marry shortly after and have a daughter, Bunny (played
by three Gainer sisters -- Alyssa, Kaitlyn, and Lauren
-- as she ages). Petal continues to sleep with
whomever she pleases, leaving Quoyle with Bunny, until
one day she takes the girl in order to sell her to a
couple.
Well, this is a bad thing, and so Petal is punished
by the gods of fictional payback: she dies when a car
driven by her latest thug-boy-toy goes off a bridge.
Traumatized yet again (and still desperately in love
with the woman whom the film has asked you to despise
pretty much without question), Quoyle can't think what
to do until his recently dead monster-father's sister,
Aunt Agnis (Judi Dench), shows up on his doorstep,
asking to take the ashes to Newfoundland for
ceremonial treatment. Taking -- what else? -- pity on
Quoyle, Agnis convinces him to bring Bunny and move
"home" with her, to discover his "roots." Soon they're
all three living in their ancestors' home, literally
tied down with cables, against recurrent ferocious
storms, and Quoyle is learning all about himself --
his family and his own capacities.
He's aided in this education by the local folk who
are, of course, all charmingly weird. (Six-year-old
Bunny's version of fitting in and finding herself
involves her own quirk, that is, being what the locals
call "sensitive," or prone to extrasensory perception,
maybe.) Hired as a reporter for the local paper,
Quoyle is assigned the "accident" beat, weekly
descriptions of car wrecks, hopefully including bloody
bodies and/or mangled autos. And so the job itself
becomes another sort of hurdle, as he keeps flashing
back to his made-up vision of Petal's accident.
For some reason, Quoyle still impresses crotchety
publisher Jack Buggit (Scott Glenn) -- who has his own
familial issues over water, concerning the
near-drowning of his son, haunted pretty boy carpenter
Dennis (Jason Behr, looking vaguely less alien than he
does in Roswell). And at the office, he's
encouraged by affable writer Nutbeem (Rhys Ifans) and
hassled by right-wingy editor Tert X. Card (Pete
Postlethwaite). These relationships vaguely suggest
Quoyle has found a community of writers, oddballs, and
anxiety-prone men, into which he might fit.
His progress is aided when he takes a fancy to
melancholy daycare supervisor Wavey (Julianne Moore).
Her gentle manner, obvious beauty, and excellent
maternal inclinations (she has a retarded son,
indicate, in movie-shorthand, that she is generous and
long-suffering, quite unlike the terrible
Petal) are only made more attractive by the fact that
she too is damaged, still mourning the loss of her
fisherman husband. Her relationship with Quoyle is
everything that you might expect in a Hallström movie
of late -- their passion is real but tentative, their
mutual needs are intense but unspeakable, and their
coupledom is bound to happen. (You have to wonder what
happened to the man who made My Life as a Dog
and Whatever Happened to Gilbert Grape?.)
In addition to finding a suitable mate, Quoyle's
emergence into something resembling adulthood involves
coming to terms with his brutal ancestors and his own
emotional limitations, both manifested as his
overcoming his fear of drowning. This particular
metaphor is, of course, no surprise, given the film's
first scene and settings, but it's over-killed
nonetheless. At least he doesn't go the way of the
decidedly non-quirky Kevin Costner in Message in a
Bottle and martyr himself on the ocean blue.
Instead, Quoyle learns to sail safely and discovers
himself along the rocky coast.
You might imagine what aspects of Quoyle's search
made him seem a likely transfer from novel to big
screen -- he's strange and yet strangely familiar,
undeveloped and yet potentially developing. The sad news is that his story is so humdrum, because the film only makes these aspects into perfunctory movie-plot touchstones. Quoyle is only strange to the extent that
he can remain sympathetic, and the other characters
are Quoyle-developing props more than individuals. His
most compelling relationship is, potentially, with
Agnis (it helps that Dench's performance is quite
resolutely un-eccentric), but then you learn that she
-- like most everyone else in sight -- has a deep dark
secret that turns her into a cliché she needn't have
been.