
Traditionally, Disney Channel tells audiences that being themselves is the key to success. For example, the popular 2006 Disney Channel Original Movie, Kenny Ortega’s High School Musical, follows a star athlete and a shy academic who defy the status quo by joining their school’s musical, while Duwayne Dunham’s Halloweentown, from 1999, centers on supernatural beings living together in their own magical world, celebrating difference and belonging. Yet behind these narratives of uniqueness and self-acceptance, the young actresses in these productions were often pressured to shrink themselves to meet narrow standards of girlhood.
Using Alyson Stoner’s career as a case study, let’s look at how Disney’s star-making system rewards certain forms of femininity while sidelining performers who don’t fit the network’s preferred image of girlhood. Note: Stoner is nonbinary and uses they/them pronouns.
Caitlyn Geller, played by Stoner and portrayed as Mitchie’s closest friend in the popular Camp Rock franchise, is known for supporting the protagonist. That dynamic mirrors Stoner’s real-life position within Disney: always reliable, always praised, yet consistently pushed to the margins. Although Stoner built a recognizable career—appearing as the little girl in Missy Elliott’s “Work It” music video, voicing Isabella in the animated television series Phineas and Ferb, playing Sarah Baker in the Cheaper by the Dozen films, and starring as Camille in the Step Up franchise—they were rarely positioned as the “main girl”.
In their 2025 memoir, Semi-Well-Adjusted Despite Literally Everything, Stoner notes that white girls who transitioned smoothly from “cute” to “pretty”, especially those who physically developed earlier, are far more likely to be cast as leads. These girls are framed as “unassuming bombshells awakening to their sexuality”. Meanwhile, girls who were less developed or deemed “average-looking”, including Stoner herself, are typecast as the “quirky best friend”, the “moody misfit”, or the girl who was “plain and unbecoming in an accessible way”. This sorting system reveals how Disney relies on appearance-based hierarchies to determine which girls are allowed to be the face of a franchise.
Stoner began their Disney career at age nine on Mike’s Super Short Show (2002-008) and by age 12—after years of steady work—they were offered the lead role in a new sitcom as Ally Parker, a character modeled directly after them. The show, a spinoff of That’s So Raven, centered on a child star who lived a double life, wearing a blonde wig at night and returning to a “normal” life during the day. Before production began, the concept was reworked, the character was renamed Miley Stewart, and the lead was given to Miley Cyrus instead.
From 2006 to 2011, Cyrus became the face of Disney Channel, with Hannah Montana (2006-11) defining the network’s peak influence on American youth, especially young girls. Its cultural impact still lasts—Disney+ viewers have streamed more than half a billion hours of the show in the past decade. Additionally, the franchise broke multiple records: the Season 1 soundtrack debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200, the 2007 Best of Both Worlds tour sold out 71 arenas across North America, and the concert documentary became the highest-grossing concert film at the time.
In her memoir, Stoner argues that girls who fit conventional beauty standards are more likely to be elevated to leading roles, while performers perceived as less conventionally attractive are often relegated to supporting characters. In this framework, Cyrus, as Hannah Montana, embodies many of the traits that the network frequently promotes in its young female leads: a thin frame, light eyes, and blonde hair. Ironically, this contrast is built directly into the Hannah Montana narrative. Hannah receives admiration, desire, and celebrity status, while Miley Stewart, without the blonde wig and glamorous persona, is positioned as an ordinary girl who often struggles for the same attention.
For example, in the series’ first two episodes, Miley’s best friend Oliver (Mitchel Musso) doesn’t know that she is, in fact, the star, Hannah Montana. He has a crush on the star persona, and hides inside Hannah’s bass drum to ride from California to Phoenix for the chance to meet the star. When he learns that Miley and Hannah are the same person, he jokingly exclaims that “it’s two years of my life I’ll never get back.” The moment reinforces the show’s central hierarchy: Hannah is viewed as exciting, glamorous, and desirable, whereas Miley is treated as the familiar girl next door. Read alongside Stoner’s observations about Disney’s preference for conventionally feminine stars, the series itself appears to reproduce the distinction between girls who are deemed worthy of attention and those relegated to supporting roles.
The hierarchy embedded within the show’s narrative also echoes the decisions that shaped its production. Cyrus initially auditioned for Lilly, the best friend role, but afterward, producers asked her to audition for the lead. Although they initially passed because she was too young, they called her back a year later when the first cast did not meet expectations. When she booked the role, the character’s name was changed from Chloe to Miley in honor of her, the well-known pop star.
Stoner appeared in only one episode of That’s So Raven, and what was supposed to be their chance to finally become a main Disney girl was reduced to a cameo appearance. This near miss marks the first time Disney repackaged Stoner’s labor while reserving the spotlight for girls who fit into a narrower, more marketable version of girlhood.
A year later, at 13, Stoner was again promised a lead role—this time in a Disney Channel Original Movie. They and an award-winning producer pitched a story about a teenage girl attending a summer music camp and navigating the challenges of girlhood. After months with no update, Disney announced auditions for an untitled Disney Channel Original Movie with the exact same premise. That would be, of course, Camp Rock. Again, Stoner was not cast as the lead; instead, they were asked to audition for the role of Mitchie Torres, and then redirected to read for Caitlyn, the supportive best friend to Demi Lovato.
Stoner memoir depicts Disney’s star-making system consistently elevating girls who fit conventional beauty and femininity ideals. Lovato embodied many of the traits that Disney frequently rewarded in its female leads, including a small waist, powerful singing voice, and marketable “cool factor”. By contrast, Stoner was often positioned as the spunky tomboy: dependable, talented, and approachable, yet rarely cast as the central girl around whom a franchise was built.
Once again, Stoner’s creative labor helped shape a project that ultimately positioned them on the sidelines, reinforcing the industry’s pattern of elevating certain girls while relegating others to secondary roles. After booking the role of Caitlyn, Stoner was still positioned mainly to support Disney’s “it girl”. In Camp Rock, Caitlyn’s colorful, playful wardrobe—pink leopard prints, armbands, and bright Converse—visually reinforces her nonthreatening role as Mitchie’s quirky, approachable best friend. She is described as reliable and helpful but rarely given a storyline of her own.
Camp Rock was a success, averaging nearly nine million viewers, outperforming High School Musical. Following the film’s success, Lovato was elevated to full “it girl” status with her own Disney series, Sonny with a Chance (2009-11) and multiple Disney Channel Original Movies, including 2010’s Camp Rock 2 and Allison Liddi-Brown’s 2009 TV movie, Princess Protection Program. Her first album debuted at No. 2 and her second at No. 1 on the Billboard 200, demonstrating a level of success that far exceeded what Stoner was allowed to achieve.
Cyrus and Lovato both embodied traits that Disney historically elevated in its young female leads. In contrast, Stoner did not fit these narrow beauty expectations, which contributed to them being repeatedly placed in supportive roles rather than positioned as a lead. Although Disney cannot strictly be blamed, the pressure to be socially attractive incurred an eating disorder and led her to present herself as ever-highly-functioning, “Smiling Girl #437”. If she couldn’t be perceived as Jessica Rabbit—sexy with a well-developed body—then she would have to be Twiggy—a body weight of 97 pounds and a triple extra small in jeans.
In many ways, Stoner continues to occupy supportive roles within Disney’s ecosystem. Ironically, their romantic role within Disney’s ecosystem takes place in an animated medium: as Isabella in Phineas and Ferb, a character whose primary function is to pine after Phineas and repeatedly ask “Whatcha doin’?”, arguably positioning her as a supportive love interest rather than a fully realized lead. Even when Stoner secured one of Disney’s most recognizable animated roles, Isabella’s characterization remains organized around emotional support and romantic devotion to the male protagonist.
Works Cited:
Carroll, L. (2009). Demi Lovato is Disney’s latest success story. Variety. 3 Deceber 2009.
Mendez, M. Why Alyson Stoner cut their gender journey from a tell-all memoir on child fame. Out Magazine.14 August 2025.
Nordyke, K. Disney’s “Camp Rock” scores big ratings. The Hollywood Reporter. 21 June 2008.
Shanfeld, E. “I wasn’t trying to kill Hannah Montana off”: Miley Cyrus on “reclaiming” the Disney icon after 20 years, getting sober and reuniting with dad Billy Ray. Variety. 18 March 2026.
Stoner, A. Alyson Stoner pens eye-opening op-ed on “harrowing” childhood stardom: “Revisit the script.” People. 7 August 2021.
Stoner, A. Semi-Well-Adjusted Despite Literally Everything: A Memoir. St. Martin’s Griffin. August 2025.
